In the
film O Brother, Where Art Thou?, three
men (Ulysses Everett McGill, Delmar, and Pete) escape from a prison chain gang
in order to find a large sum of money ($1.2 million). The treasure turns out to
be made up by Everett, who escaped from the prison chain gang in an effort to get
his wife back and stop her from marrying someone else. On their adventures, the
three men encounter many characters and events that are reminiscent of those in
Homer’s Odyssey. The blind man with
the hand-powered railway car is reminiscent of the blind prophet Teiresias. He
informs the three men that they will in fact find a treasure, but not the one which
they seek – perhaps a reference to their future musical success as the Soggy
Bottom Boys. Another important similarity between O Brother, Where Art Thou? and The
Odyssey is the fact that Everret’s first name is Ulysses and his wife’s
name is Penny (short for Penelope). In The
Odyssey, Odysseus’s wife Penelope must deal with unwanted suitors, for it
was presumed that Odysseus had died during the fall of Troy (in Everett’s case,
Penny said that he was hit by a train). Additionally, in the Roman version of The Odyssey, Odysseus was known as
Ulysses.
Some
other character parallels that could be drawn between the two stories include
Big Dan and the Cyclops (both have one eye), the three women by the river and
the Sirens (fairly obvious), & Sherriff Cooley (who is unnamed in the film
but fits Tommy’s description of the devil/Satan) and Poseidon. In The Odyssey, Odysseus and his men escape
from the Cyclops by tying themselves to the undersides of sheep being let out
to pasture. In a somewhat parallel scene, Everett, Delmar, and Pete are able to
infiltrate a KKK meeting and rescue Tommy from being lynched by dressing up in Klan
robes and blinding Big Dan (the Cyclops) with a fiery cross. Throughout the
film, Everett, Delmar, and Pete are being chased by Sherriff Cooley and his
henchmen. Even after being pardoned by the mayor (somewhat analogous to Zeus) after
their first public performance as The Soggy Bottom Boys, Sherriff Cooley still
attempts to lynch the three men as punishment for escaping the prison chain
gang. This draws direct parallels to Poseidon’s actions in The Odyssey, who spends the large majority of the myth making Odysseus’
journey home very difficult as a punishment for blinding the Cyclops (who was
Poseidon’s son).
Very good. I like the poseidon commentary and also the major as zeus; although he is also called Menelaus Pappy O Daniel and menalous was the husband of Helen of Troy.
ReplyDeleteAhh, I didn't catch that his first name was Menelaus.
ReplyDeleteI didn't realize that Ulysses and Odysseus both had wives with similar names! That's such a cool subtle reference to the Odyssey.
ReplyDeleteI really didn't think about the cyclops reference even though it's pretty major.
ReplyDeleteI think you make really great points. I definitely have to agree that the blind man resembled Tiresias completely. You make a lot of other interesting parallels that I didn't even notice; great post!
ReplyDeleteI never thought about the names! I figured that Ulysses/Odysseus were close but it's been forever since I've read The Odyssey so I completely forgot about the Penny/Penelope connection. Good catch!
ReplyDeleteI didn't pick up on the fact that the sheriff personified Tommy's description of the devil. I did attribute him as a parallel to Poseidon. It makes me wonder of the Coen brothers interpreted Poseidon as a villain in the Odyssey. As sheriff, you'd think that he was supposed to be a symbol of good and justice when in the film, he's really not. That's seen when he blatantly ignores the group's admission that the governor pardoned them and decides to hang them anyway.
ReplyDeleteI like the comparison you made between the part of the Odyssey to the scene in the movie about the KKK. Those two parts are quite similar to each other, in that both of them involved some sneaky creativity to accomplish their goal.
ReplyDeleteGreat analogy! I never really though of it that way, but Mt. Olympus is kind of like the Capitol in that each Senator (god) has their own personal agendas, yet they form coalitions with one another in order to achieve objectives that satisfy as many people as possible.
ReplyDelete